Clicky

Eyeliner Reviews - Your Guide To the Best Eyeliners in Town

picture of angelina jolie with dark eyelinerEyeliner is the perfect cosmetic tool to take your look from casual to glam in one easy step! Eyeliner comes in a variety of forms, from pencils and powders to dramatic liquids. You can customize these to produce a variety of results, from an everyday smudged look to a smoky evening appearance. A wide selection of colors can be found to match your mood. Dark browns and subtle grays are perfect for everyday wear, and bold blues and metallics can be the perfect addition to your evening look.

For more dramatic events, a liquid eyeliner can make a bold statement and draw attention directly to your eyes. For those who want their look to last from morning to night, eyeliner is also made in smudge-proof and water-proof forms. This will ensure that your look will stay fresh from the time you put it on until you remove it at night.

There are many top eyeliners on the market, and some of the best eyeliners can be found anywhere from drugstores to department stores. The easiest way to find which one is right for you is by researching eyeliner reviews and other women's experiences. By reading what others say, you can determine which of type of eyeliner you'd like to try. Eyeliner can be the finishing touch to your makeup regimen and can add an extra bit of detail to your everyday appearance!

Read our eyeliner reviews below to help you pick different eye liners for different looks and occasions.

Urban Decay 247_doubleended_duo

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Double-Ended Eye Pencil Set Review

Urban Decay rarely disappoints, especially when it comes to eye makeup. Here we have UD’s 4 basic colors matched with a handy sharper to stuff your bestie’s stockings with. I know my bestie would be pleased with this gift. She is a big Urban Decay fan as most you readers are (me three!). I a... Read More »

Site Score
8.5
Image of Elf's Liquid Eyeliner in Coffee

ELF Liquid Eyeliner in Coffee Review

I have a confession to make: I can not apply liquid eye liner to save my life, and I’m not too sure that ELF Liquid Eyeliner in Coffee is going to be any different. I just don’t get on very well with liquid liners for whatever reason. Maybe it’s because my hand-eye coordination is ... Read More »

Site Score
6.2
MAC Carbon Eyeshadow Review

MAC Carbon Eyeshadow Review

The MAC Carbon eyeshadow is a matte black shade that can be used in various degrees of intensity. It can be built up to a deep dark black, or just a muted dark gray. I’m always on the lookout for the best matte black, and Carbon has always come up as one of the top contenders along with Make Up Fo... Read More »

Site Score
7.0
MAC Eye Kohl Smolder Product Image

MAC Eye Kohl in Smolder Review

I have a bit of a love-hate relationship with MAC Eye Kohl. I love it for its many good qualities, but I hate it because it does have its flaws as well. However, I still believe that it is a great product–one that I’m really happy to have in my stash. I love using MAC Eye Kohl in Smolde... Read More »

Site Score
7.0
NYX Retractable Eyeliner Review

NYX Retractable Eyeliner Review

If you ask me what my makeup must-haves are, I’d answer with BB cream, concealer, face powder, lipstick, eyebrow pencil/powder, AND eyeliner. I can be without mascara, but not eyeliner and I’ve always been on the lookout for great ones that won’t end up on my cheeks at the end of t... Read More »

Site Score
9.5
The Body Shop Eye Definer (White) Review

The Body Shop Eye Definer (White) Review

In need of a white pencil to highlight the lower lash line, I thought I picked up this eye liner while I was shopping at The Body Shop. You know one of those times when you defiantly go against your gut feeling just to prove yourself wrong? Wrong decision! I tested out on the spot and the pencil... Read More »

Site Score
4.0
Korres Soft Eyeliner Pencil in White Review

Korres Soft Eyeliner Pencil in White Review

There’s a very simple trick used in the beauty industry that one of my girlfriend taught me: white eyeliner on your inner lid of your lower lash line to open up the eyes. This eye-opening effect can be emphasized with more pigment around the inner corner of eyes. Metallic colors go very well with ... Read More »

Site Score
8.7